Convictions and prison terms
A panel of five judges convicted Aurelien Lapersonne, 29, Philippe Tondeux, 50, and Pierre Plantier, 37, for the 2020 beating of black music producer Michel Zecler in Paris. The court found the assault included an aggravated circumstance of racism and that the officers signed a falsified police report claiming the 47-year-old Zecler had violently resisted arrest. The court issued five year sentences for all three men, where Lapersonne received three years suspended, Tondeux received three and a half years suspended, and Plantier received four years suspended plus one year with an ankle monitor. All three officers were told they can never serve in the police force again. The verdict provides accountability for the officers who lied. Critics used the incident to argue that it exposed systematic racism among officers.
Details of the studio attack
The incident occurred during the 2020 Covid lockdown when officers accused Zecler of not wearing a mask as he approached his studio on foot. The police entered the lobby without a warrant and tried to force Zecler outside, which caused a beating where he suffered 30 punches, kicks, and baton strikes. The court preferred the evidence provided by Zecler because, unlike the three officers, everything the producer said during the two-week trial was verifiably true regarding the assault and the racial slur used. While the officers admitted to the beating and the faked report in court, they denied any racial motivation. Zecler told the court during the trial that "if it had not been for the CCTV video, he would have been in court not as a victim but as a potential criminal."
The officers claimed that Zecler’s behavior aroused their suspicions and that they thought he might be carrying drugs, though no evidence emerged to support that suspicion. People from the basement pushed the police outside, which caused the officers to smash a glass pane and send a tear-gas grenade into the building, after which Zecler was hit again before his arrest. In their last words before the court, the officers apologized for what they had done, and Tondeux expressed regret "for the image of the police that I have given".


